
Earlier this week when feeding the fish, I noticed one of my J. marksmithi juveniles lying partially upright on the bottom of the 20g long, species only tank in which it resides.
I have not been able to take a clean photo of my marksmithi because they’re quite shy. However, the photo at the top is a good example of this beautiful species.
Thinking maybe the upright fish was just resting, I reached into the tank just to be sure. Any healthy fish would have immediately fled my hand. It didn’t move. I realized then it was dead.
Losing fish happens, even to the best fish keepers. Therefore, while upset that I lost one, I didn’t get overly concerned. I still had four juveniles…or so I thought.
The marksmithi tank is pretty densely occupied with caves and rocks such that there is ample cover and hiding places for all of the juveniles. After removing the dead fish, I began looking around the tank to make sure the other four were still alive. I noticed one in the corner that was upright but wasn’t moving. I reached down for it, same as I did for the other one. The result? The same. Another dead marksmithi.
Finding two dead fish in the same tank at the same time, both of which were alive the night before, is highly unusual and quite disconcerting.
So, what happened? I am not sure. I set the tank up using a seeded sponge from another tank the first of the month, so I am confident it is not a water issue. I had tested the water a couple of weeks ago, and it was fine. Therefore, if it’s not a water issue, it must be aggression. I have kept Julies long enough to know, that even with adequate cover, a fish can get picked off by aggression. One of the original five marksmithi (not one of the dead ones) is a bit larger than the others. I also recognized that it had also established itself in the center of the tank under a Texas holey rock.
The aggression doesn’t surprise me, necessarily, but two tankmates dying this way, especially with them all still being juveniles demonstrates a level of aggression I have not experienced with Julies. In fact, I had not personally witnessed any chasing or aggression when observing the tank.
Yes, this is my first time keeping marksmithi, but I have kept almost all other species of Julies and have never witnessed this. While I know it is recommended to keep multiples of this species in larger tanks (> 80g [300 liters]), my fish are juveniles at only 2″ (5 cm). Adults get twice this size. So, I initially didn’t think the 20g long (30″) would be an issue. I have kept many of the smaller Julie species in a 20g long before and had no problems. In fact, my most prolific trio (one male and two females) of Julidochromis dickfeldi reside in a 20g long now.
Perhaps I was mistaken and should have opted to put them in one of the larger tanks. Losing fish is bad enough. Losing them because of a mistake I made is much harder to accept.
Hope this tank is stabilizing. We keep a lot of the same fish and I’ve seen similar losses in my tanks. Try as I do to remove bullied fish they don’t like to be caught and getting them out of the nooks and crannies is sometimes tough without emptying it out. I have a group of 6 J. marlieri right now at a similar size also in a 20L. Watching them carefully it looks like I have two establishing territories am similarly concerned for the others. Going to move them to a larger tank soon. Best of luck.
Hey Craig,
Thanks for the note. Indeed I am more convinced this is an aggression issue. In the past couple of days, I have noticed two of the remaining juveniles sticking together in a corner of the tank. That is indicative of aggression, IMO. I don’t know the sexes of the fish yet. I had hoped with the group of five that I would have received at least a male AND female, but I honestly don’t know what I have. If what I have left is three males, that’s a problem. Thinking about the possible ratio of the five I got, I can’t imagine the two that got picked off were females.
Like you, I think I am going to have to pull the two fish being pushed to the margins and rehome them. I hadn’t planned on this so early, so not entirely sure what tanks I am going to move them to. I don’t have a ton of options w/o setting up something new.
Hope you enjoy those marlieri. I had good luck with that species when I kept them a few years ago.
Scott