Juvenile giant danios in 45g shell dweller tank. Photo by the author.
Normally, I don’t keep anything other than cichlids. This means I typically don’t have dither fish or other schooling fish. However, because I am preparing for some new cichlids and I have a couple of sparsely populated tanks, I wanted to boost the beneficial bacteria in their respective filters.
Last night I was thinking about my fish. Being the self-reflective type, I thought about my fish keeping journey and the factors that have led me to where I am now. Ultimately, I began to think about how I decide upon what species to keep. This is a long post.
It has been a while since I posted an interview. However, I hope to have several on the way soon. I have two that I am in the process of formatting and editing. Those should be going up in the very near future.
I have two others still in the early stages but hope to have those up within a couple of months.
Adult ‘Lamprologus’ signatus outside apple snail shell. Photo by the author.
This is a pretty juicy subject. Depending on who you ask, you’ll get several answers. Is there one “right” answer? No. Why? Because that depends on your intent with the question.
Word cloud. Image created at https://wordart.com/.
If you’ve viewed the FAQ page on the blog, you know why I choose to keep dwarf cichlids, specifically Africans. One reason that I haven’t listed has to do with ethics. Yes, there is a fair argument that keeping any animal, domesticated or undomesticated, is unethical.
Adult male ‘Lamprologus’ caudopunctatus (foreground) and adult Labidochromis sp. ‘Red top Hongi’ (larger blue-colored fish hiding under the slate rock) together in a 75g tank. Photo by the author.
I very often hear of cichlid keepers with mixed tanks. Some keep New World and Old World cichlids together. Some keep Tangs with Malawis and some even keep West Africans with East Africans. Does it really matter? Sure….sometimes. It depends on several factors.
What about keeping mbuna with Tanganyikan shell dwellers? “Blasphemous!” some might say. I would say, “Not so fast.” Different lake origins and water parameter requirements aside, it can be done. I know because I do it. But should you?
33g long aquarium containing Julidochromis dickfeldi and ‘Lamprologus’ ocellatus. Photo by the author.
Yes and no. Answers to that question depend on several factors. However, for one example of why you should not allow a breeding pair of cichlids to have multiple broods in the same tank, look no further than Julidochromis dickfeldi. Many species of cichlids can get along just fine with multiple generations of their own offspring, especially shell dwelling species. However, some adult cichlid pairs consider an older brood a threat to the newest brood and will treat the older brood(s) accordingly.
Dr. Alex Jordan on Lake Tanganyika. Photo by Jakob Guebel.
If you follow the blog, you know I have interviewed all kinds of cichlid enthusiasts, from business people to scientists to hobbyists. Because I have a fondness for Lake Tanganyika cichlids, it’s always a treat when I get to interview someone who’s dived the lake and can provide first-hand knowledge of some of the lake’s species.