
Interviews are a key component of my blog, and interviewees are a combination of people I know and don’t know. Today’s interviewee falls into the latter category. I learned of Andy Hudson because he was recently on the ballot for a Board of Trustees position with the American Cichlid Association (ACA). I was intrigued by his bio, so I reached out to him.
He is a long time aquarist, having begun his fish keeping journey when he was only 10, going on to work at a fish store at 15. After attending college and earning a bachelors degree in aquaculture, he went back to work at the same fish store for a few more years. In 2006, he began a professional career in the fish industry, accepting a job at Central Aquatics in Franklin, WI working in research and development, a position he still holds today.
As a member of several fish organizations, including the Milwaukee Aquarium Society (where he is treasurer), Andy has won numerous awards and has achieved Ultimate breeder status. He has bred more than 187 species of fish but considers cichlids, especially South Americans, some of his favorites. His modest fish room of 35 tanks keeps him busy when not working or spending time with his family.
Let’s dive in!
One of your favorite cichlid tribes is Geophagini, which includes pikes and eartheaters. Why Geophagines?
It’s a tough question to answer. I started keeping geophagines in the 1990’s with some Satanoperca daemon that the store I worked at had brought in. Before that I was keeping mostly Africans. Sadly, I had to part with them when I moved to Wisconsin, but I soon picked up some Geophagus altifrons and spawned them and from then on it was all downhill. I think it has to do with their peaceful demeanor, stunning colors, and interesting behavior that really makes me love them so.
Two of your favorite species are Geophagus mirabilis and Geophagus sveni. What makes these special to you?
I acquired and spawned mirabilis a few years back and just recently spawned G. sveni. In terms of colors, I have to say they are probably the most stunning eartheaters. The mirabilis have just amazing blues that really sparkle when the light hits them just right. Sveni have blue, red, and green and have the long dorsal and caudal filaments that make them a stunning fish.

I don’t have much on the blog about eartheaters. In your experience, what should cichlidophiles know in order to be successful keeping and even breeding these fish?
I think the most important thing is that they need clean, soft water, and a sand bottom. They aren’t herbivorous fish but that doesn’t mean they are safe with plants as they will dig up any rooted plants. Plants tied to rocks or driftwood are fine. I use Anubias and Java fern mainly, but Bucephelandra are also good. You can keep them with just about any peaceful fish that is bigger than their mouth. I have had them occasionally eat a small tetra or cory cat. But larger fish are fine. A pair of most species can be kept in a 40 breeder, but I prefer 75 gallons or larger for any groups of 4 or more.
Feed sinking pellets, flakes, frozen, or live foods. They aren’t picky. The sand is important as they will spend a lot of their time sifting it.
To breed them, you will need a piece of smooth slate as a spawning substrate. They are delayed mouthbrooders, which means they will lay eggs on a surface and then the female will chew the larvae out of the egg about 48-72 hours later and mouthbrood them. They will release the fry about 12-14 days later. I prefer to strip the females after about 10-11 days and raise artificially, but you can also siphon them out of the tank once they are released. Unless the pair is alone, the fry usually get eaten by other fish.
I feed baby brine shrimp in the evening with a powdered fry food fed in the morning. Broods for eartheaters are much larger than African mouthbrooders with hundreds of fry produced at a time. I start them in a 10 gallon until they are about ½ inch then move to a 40 breeder to grow. Frequent water changes are necessary to get good growth. I use straight up RO water without any additives. Some minerals leach out of the rocks, the substrate, and the food that is fed so there is a little GH and KH, but it’s very low.
What’s on your cichlid bucket list and why?
Right now, Geophagus mirabilis is back on my bucket list. Although I have already kept and spawned them, they are pretty much absent from the hobby in North America, and I would like to bring them back. I recently saw some for sale from an importer but at 5X the price I paid for them when I had them last, which was just too much for me. I have also so far not been able to spawn any of the Retroculus. I have some R. lapidifer and have kept R. xinguensis in the past but I just don’t have the right tanks setup for them to spawn. So someday I hope to setup some new tanks specifically for them and try again. I am also getting back into Africans a little bit and have added some Tanganyikans to my fish room. Benthochromis tricoti is a species I would love to try and breed someday.
Let’s talk about your fish room. What have you learned over the years that makes maintaining so many tanks easier?
I am currently on my 5th fish room. I have learned a little bit from each iteration on how to make it better. It’s still not perfect, and not nearly as technologically advanced as some of the fantastic fish rooms in the upper Midwest, but it works for me.
The most important thing is humidity control. Being in Wisconsin, heat management is essential and it’s far more economical to heat the whole room than using individual heaters. I use an electric heat pump that also works as an AC unit to maintain the room temperature. I also have an air exchanger to circulate fresh air in and remove excess humidity. Mold and mildew can destroy a fish room.

My current fish room is a modified room that was originally part of the garage, and there is an air gap between it and the house so I don’t have to worry about excess humidity getting into the house. The next most important thing is storing water and making water changes easier. I made sure my new fish room had room for two 50 gallon drums for storing RO water. I also had all the largest tanks drilled for water drains. This way I can press a button and do water changes on all these tanks at once. I don’t do this on my smaller tanks as I often need to siphon the bottoms. For those, I installed a floor drain trench that runs the length of the fish room and I can just drain onto the floor instead of into a sink. Note: Next time I would invest more in sloping the entire floor of the fish room towards the drain and smoothing it out better.
You have a degree in aquaculture. How has this contributed to your success as a fish keeper?
I used to joke that an aquaculture degree is the same as a marine biology degree but not having to learn about dolphins or birds. The biggest thing I got out of my aquaculture degree was the last year of school, working on actual fish farms in Florida. I spent time on a clam farm, shrimp farm, and tropical fish farm. The clam and shrimp showed how important it was to maintain cleanliness and sterility when working with larvae. Contamination can cause whole vats to collapse almost overnight. It’s great practice for raising fish. The tropical fish farm taught me the techniques for raising cichlids and other fish and was by far the most inspiring. It gave me the knowledge and love of the commercial side of the hobby, which has guided my career for the rest of my life.
You’ve achieved Ultimate Breeder status in your local club. I’ve posed the following question to a couple of interviewees before. If Master Cichlid Keeper was a formal accolade/title in the hobby, what would you consider the criteria necessary to achieve it?
That’s an interesting question. I think the biggest criteria is that they would have to spawn at least one or more species from each of the different types of cichlids. Breeding Apistogramma is a lot different than breeding mbuna and you would need to require the aquarist to step out of their comfort zone. As far as how many species total? That’s a good question. I would think it would have to be at least 3 dozen different species. The problem with this has always been validation. How do you validate it? Different groups have tried but it becomes difficult without enough judges spread around the country to validate submissions. That’s why BAP programs are pretty much a local program.
If you could change three things about the cichlid hobby tomorrow, what would they be?
I would like to see more cooperation between governments and cichlid hobbyists to conserve cichlids. There is this never-ending cycle of a species becoming rare (mainly by habitat destruction) and then the government cuts off trade to “protect” it. This leads to an increase in the desirability of hobbyists to own the fish and a rise in illegal trade. This does nothing to preserve the species. It would be far better for governments and hobbyists to work together to identify species in danger and develop plans with hobbyists to develop commercial aquaculture of the species. Hobbyists would have to also reject the illegal trade of threatened species and embrace aquacultured species. Unfortunately, legislation, domestic and international, does not support such a partnership, and there are many groups out there that would stop all international trade if they had their way (even if it means the extinction of a species).
The other thing I would change is the way hybrids are distributed in the hobby. I have nothing against hybrids if they are clearly marked. But when hybrids are passed off as wild type fish it annoys me. It makes it impossible to maintain pure lines as these hybrids can spread through the hobby and become misidentified. Aquarists have a duty to maintain accurate records of their fish. Lastly, I wish more people kept Geophagus!
Anything that we didn’t discuss above that you would like to mention or comment on related to the hobby?
The only other thing I would add is that the list of benefits of joining a local aquarium society and/or a national association like the American Cichlid Association are immeasurable. Access to fish you won’t see in stores and the knowledge of thousands of other aquarists are incredible resources to new aquarists. Demographics of most aquarium societies are aging out and, if we want to continue to maintain these valuable organizations, we need new and younger members to join. If you ever get the opportunity, consider attending one of the annual ACA conventions. You won’t be disappointed.